← Back to Blog
Guide

47 Questions to Ask in a 3PL RFP (with Scoring)

47 questions to ask a 3PL in an RFP or questionnaire, grouped into systems, processes, operations and execution, with a scoring method to compare proposals.

By Hylke Reitsma · Founder & Supply Chain Specialist · Replit Race to Revenue Cohort #1

Hylke Reitsma is founder of Forthsuite and a supply chain specialist with 8+ years of hands-on experience at Shell, Verisure, and Stryker. He holds an MSc in Supply Chain Management from the University of Groningen and writes practical guides to help e-commerce teams run leaner, faster supply chains. Selected by Replit as 1 of 20 founders for the inaugural Race to Revenue Cohort #1 (2026) and certified as a Replit Platform Builder.

12 min read
Modern warehouse interior with organized inventory and digital technology interfaces highlighted by warm amber lighting
In this article

TL;DR: Use these 47 questions to compare a 3PL’s systems, processes, operations, knowledge and execution. The displayed weights are starting points to adapt to your requirements, not industry benchmarks or proof of provider quality. Score documented evidence consistently and check essential capabilities separately. Forthmatch’s app monitors connected Shopify records; it does not verify all RFP answers.

Looking for a 3PL for your online store? Request quotes from directory providers that fit (no account needed).

Last updated: 5 November 2026. This is a procurement checklist, not hands-on provider testing or an independently validated scoring standard.

Choosing a third-party logistics (3PL) provider can make or break your ecommerce operation. The right partner handles your inventory with care, ships orders accurately, and scales with your business. The wrong one creates headaches: lost products, delivery delays, and angry customers. A structured request for proposal (RFP) separates serious contenders from poor fits. This guide covers 47 questions to ask in a free 3PL RFP template (with scoring) to help you evaluate providers objectively and choose the best match for your Shopify store. Understanding these questions helps you make better decisions about your fulfillment partner.

Understanding the SPOKE Framework for 3PL RFPs

This guide uses SPOKE to organize questions into five categories: Systems, Processes, Operations, Knowledge and Execution. It is a checklist structure for this guide, not a certification or a guarantee that every requirement for your business is covered.

Systems covers technology infrastructure, integrations, and data visibility. Processes examines standard operating procedures, quality controls, and workflow design. Operations looks at physical facilities, equipment, and capacity. Knowledge assesses industry expertise, compliance awareness, and training programs. Execution measures actual performance metrics, SLAs, and accountability measures.

Adapt the suggested weights to your business before issuing the RFP. Define what earns full, partial or zero points, what evidence is required, and which missing capabilities rule a provider out. Use the same written criteria for each provider; a score supports a decision but does not make it objective proof of quality.

Systems Questions: Technology and Integration Capabilities (12 Questions)

Check the actual Shopify connection, data ownership and exception workflow. A native connector or a short sync interval does not eliminate duplicate messages, stock mismatches or overselling; test the behavior you depend on.

Core Integration Questions:

  • Does your WMS integrate natively with Shopify? (5 points: Request supported objects, events, directions, limits and failure tests.)
  • What is your API uptime percentage over the past 12 months? (4 points: Request the measurement period, exclusions, incident history and recovery evidence; compare against your availability requirement.)
  • How frequently do inventory levels sync with our Shopify store? (5 points: Confirm update timing, reservations and reconciliation; test concurrent orders and delayed messages.)
  • Can we access order status updates in real-time? (4 points: Essential for customer service)
  • Do you provide a client portal for inventory visibility? (3 points: Self-service reduces email back-and-forth)

Reporting and Analytics Questions:

  • What standard reports do you provide daily, weekly, and monthly? (4 points: Request sample reports)
  • Can we build custom reports or dashboards? (3 points: Useful but not critical)
  • How do you track and report on inventory accuracy? (5 points: Define the count method, population, exclusions and target, and request recent evidence.)
  • What visibility do we have into order exceptions and issues? (4 points: Proactive alerts matter)
  • Can you provide SKU-level performance data? (3 points: Helps identify slow-moving inventory)

Data Security Questions:

  • What security-assurance reports and certifications can you provide? (4 points: Request current security-assurance reports or certifications and check their scope, period and exceptions.)
  • How do you handle data backups and disaster recovery? (4 points: Ask for specific RPO and RTO numbers)

Processes Questions: Quality and Workflow Standards (10 Questions)

Process questions reveal how a 3PL maintains accuracy, handles exceptions, and manages quality control. Poor processes lead to shipping errors, inventory shrinkage, and customer complaints.

Receiving and Put-Away:

  • What is your receiving process timeline from dock to system entry? (4 points: Agree receiving milestones, priorities and exception handling for your inbound mix.)
  • How do you verify inbound shipment accuracy? (5 points: Ask about physical counts, photo documentation, and discrepancy handling)
  • What happens when received quantities don't match ASNs? (4 points: Clear escalation procedures matter)
  • How do you handle product with expiration dates or lot numbers? (5 points for food, beauty, or supplement brands: FIFO/FEFO capabilities required)

Picking and Packing:

  • What is your pick accuracy rate? (5 points: Define the accuracy measure and request comparable, recent evidence against your agreed target.)
  • Do you use barcode scanning for all picks? (5 points: Ask which steps are scanned, how exceptions are handled and how accuracy is measured.)
  • How do you handle multi-item orders to ensure completeness? (4 points: Weight verification or scan-to-pack systems reduce mistakes)
  • What quality control checkpoints exist before shipping? (4 points: Ask how inspection samples are chosen, what they detect and how defects are escalated.)
  • Can you accommodate custom packaging or branded inserts? (3 points: Important for brand experience)
  • How do you manage packaging materials and minimize waste? (2 points: Compare product protection, material use and complete packaging/shipping costs.)

Operations Questions to Include in Your 3PL RFP (11 Questions)

Operational capabilities determine whether a 3PL can physically handle your volume, product types, and growth trajectory. These questions address facilities, equipment, and capacity.

Facility and Capacity:

  • How many square feet is your facility, and what percentage is currently occupied? (5 points: Confirm usable space, labor and equipment capacity reserved for your actual growth and peak assumptions.)
  • What are your current daily order volumes, and what is your maximum capacity? (5 points: Test the capacity needed for your own normal, peak and exception workloads.)
  • Do you operate multiple facilities, and can you split our inventory for faster delivery? (3 points: Model delivery lanes, carrier services, inventory allocation and transfer costs before assuming a network improves the result.)
  • What is your facility's climate control capability? (4-5 points for temperature-sensitive products)
  • How do you handle seasonal volume spikes? (5 points: Request case studies from Q4 peak season)

Equipment and Handling:

  • What material handling equipment do you use (3 points: Request evidence of the throughput, accuracy and exception handling needed for your products.)
  • Can you handle oversized, fragile, or hazmat products? (5 points if applicable to your catalog)
  • What is your process for damaged inventory identification and quarantine? (4 points: Ask how damage is identified, recorded, quarantined and resolved; photographs support investigation but do not prevent every dispute.)

Returns Management:

  • What is your returns processing timeline and restocking fee? (5 points: Agree receipt, inspection, resolution and restocking deadlines for the actual return types.)
  • How do you inspect returned items and determine restockability? (4 points: Define inspection and disposition criteria, financial records and stock reconciliation.)
  • Can you handle exchanges, refurbishment, or donation programs? (3 points: Value-add services for sustainability-focused brands)

Knowledge and Execution Questions for SPOKE Scoring (14 Questions)

Industry Knowledge:

  • How many years have you specialized in ecommerce fulfillment? (3 points: Ask for relevant operating history and current references; years in business alone do not establish service quality.)
  • What percentage of your clients are Shopify merchants? (4 points: Shopify-specific experience matters)
  • Which industries do you specialize in? (4 points if they have experience with your product category)
  • How do you stay current with carrier requirements and shipping regulations? (3 points: Ask who monitors relevant requirements and how operational changes are implemented.)
  • What is your team's training program for new employees? (3 points: Review training, supervision and current competency checks.)

Performance Metrics and SLAs:

  • What is your average order processing time (5 points: Define the start/end events, cutoff, time zone, calendar and exclusions against your required service.)
  • What percentage of orders ship on time? (5 points: Agree the on-time definition, population and target, then request the underlying evidence.)
  • What is your inventory accuracy rate? (5 points: Define the count method, stock population and acceptable variance against your requirements.)
  • How do you measure and report on KPIs? (4 points: Agree reporting frequency, definitions, data access and discrepancy handling.)
  • What penalties or credits apply if you miss SLA targets? (4 points: Financial accountability matters)

Account Management and Communication:

  • Who will be our primary point of contact, and what are their response time commitments? (4 points: Agree contact coverage, response targets, time zones and escalation ownership.)
  • How do you handle urgent issues or emergency requests? (5 points: Ask for specific escalation procedures and after-hours contact)
  • What is your average client retention rate? (4 points: Ask for the definition, cohort and reasons for departures; retention alone does not prove satisfaction.)
  • Can you provide three client references in our industry and volume range? (5 points: Always check references and ask about hidden issues)

Scoring Your 3PL RFP Responses and Making the Decision

Keep the point value printed beside each question. Give full points when a provider shows it meets your requirement, half points when it meets part of it, and zero when it cannot meet it. Use the same evidence rule for every provider and record why you gave each score.

Mark requirements that would rule a provider out before adding the points. A high total cannot make up for a missing integration or handling capability your operation needs. Compare the category scores as well as the total, then check references and contract terms before deciding.

Common RFP Mistakes to Avoid

Choose a shortlist you can evaluate properly using your product, volume, geography, integration and handling requirements.

Give each shortlisted provider the same requirements and order data, and agree a realistic response date. Record assumptions and unanswered questions so the proposals remain comparable.

Avoid vague questions like "How do you ensure quality?" Specific questions get useful answers. Instead ask: "What is your pick accuracy rate for the past six months, and how do you calculate it?"

Don't skip the reference check step. Speak with at least two current clients of each finalist. Ask about problems, not just strengths. Questions like "What took you by surprise after onboarding?" and "If you could change one thing about working with them, what would it be?" reveal helpful information.

Compare total cost under the same order and service assumptions. Include receiving, storage, shipping, returns, exceptions and the cost of measured errors; a lower rate or a single error percentage alone does not establish which provider costs less overall.

Review minimum commitments, price changes, service definitions, exit notice, inventory-transfer charges and dispute procedures before signing. Confirm how these terms affect a transition and obtain appropriate contract advice for your situation.

Use the checklist and its evidence notes to compare candidates, then confirm the selected operation and contract. Forthmatch separately reports processing time and fulfillment success from connected Shopify records and checks configured timing thresholds; it does not measure every warehouse or contract criterion in this RFP.

Track how your current 3PL actually performs — Forthmatch, free for Shopify stores.

Get Forthmatch on the Shopify App Store →

Frequently Asked Questions

What questions should I ask when evaluating a 3PL provider?

When evaluating a 3PL provider, ask about their technology integration capabilities, shipping accuracy rates, order fulfillment speed, pricing structure, and scalability options. Key questions should cover warehouse locations, returns management, customer service response times, and experience with businesses similar to yours. The SPOKE framework provides 47 essential questions with scoring criteria to help you systematically evaluate potential partners and make data-driven decisions.

How do I score responses in a 3PL RFP process?

Use the point value beside each question in this RFP. Award full, half or zero points against the same written requirements for every provider. Record the reason for each score, then check your essential requirements separately before comparing totals.

What does SPOKE mean in 3PL evaluation?

SPOKE is the structure this guide uses for Systems, Processes, Operations, Knowledge and Execution. The 47 questions are a starting checklist. Add product, regulatory, integration, commercial and risk requirements specific to your operation; covering these categories alone does not establish that every essential issue has been assessed.

Why do I need a structured RFP for choosing a 3PL partner?

A structured RFP gives candidates a common set of requirements and a record of their answers. Its usefulness depends on the questions, evidence checks and follow-through. It does not guarantee better contract terms, lower costs, customer satisfaction or a successful provider selection.

How can Forthmatch help with 3PL selection?

Forthmatch’s separate quote-request service forwards your requirements to directory providers that fit the stated region and volume; a request does not verify capabilities or guarantee a response. After choosing a provider, its Shopify monitoring app reports processing time and fulfillment success from connected records and checks configured thresholds. Warehouse accuracy, physical handoff, delivery completeness and other RFP criteria need additional evidence.

47 Questions to Ask in a 3PL RFP (with Scoring)?

Use these 47 questions and adaptable weights to compare documented 3PL capabilities. Treat scores as a decision aid, check essential requirements separately, and verify proposed services and contract terms. Forthmatch monitors connected Shopify records; it does not independently validate every RFP answer.

Need a 3PL for your online store?

Tell us your store, monthly order volume and shipping regions in one short form. Any store platform works. We forward the request to providers from the free ForthMatch 3PL directory that fit, and they reply to you directly with their own pricing.

Request 3PL quotes (no account needed)
Forthmatch Shopify Guide

About the Author

Hylke Reitsma
Hylke Reitsma Founder & Supply Chain Specialist · Replit Race to Revenue Cohort #1

Hylke Reitsma is founder of Forthsuite and a supply chain specialist with 8+ years of hands-on experience at Shell, Verisure, and Stryker. He holds an MSc in Supply Chain Management from the University of Groningen and writes practical guides to help e-commerce teams run leaner, faster supply chains. Selected by Replit as 1 of 20 founders for the inaugural Race to Revenue Cohort #1 (2026) and certified as a Replit Platform Builder.

LinkedIn
← Back to Blog

Hold your 3PL accountable with real data

Free 3PL performance tracking, SLA alerts, and accountability tools for Shopify merchants.

Install Free